• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Home
  • About
    • Disclosure & Policies
  • Contact
  • Requests
  • Winners
  • Everything Books
  • Bookish Life
  • Secondary Navigation Social Media Icons

    • Facebook
    • Goodreads
    • Instagram

Storied Conversation

every story begins a conversation

  • Home
  • About
    • Disclosure & Policies
  • Contact
  • Requests
  • Winners
  • Everything Books
  • Bookish Life

Mistaken Identity by Lani Lynn Vale | Book Review

Sep. 09, 2025

Mistaken Identity by Lani Lynn Vale | Book Review

Have you ever picked up a book thinking you knew what to expect—only to be blindsided, heartbroken, and then completely healed again within just a few chapters? Mistaken Identity is that book. By chapter four, I had tears streaming down my face, and by the end, I was absolutely in love with Audric, Creole, and the emotional journey they take together.

Mistaken Identity by Lani Lynn Vale | Book Reviewfive-stars
Mistaken Identity by Lani Lynn Vale
Series: Content Advisory #5
Genres: Romantic Suspense

From the moment Creole Williams met Audric Ingram, they were inseparable.

But not the way one would think.

They shared a best friend.

What they did not do, however, was like each other.

You could say that it was a war to win the best friend title.

The only problem was, their best friend would never choose a clear winner. So they spent their teenage years fighting it out. What Audric didn’t know, though, was that Creole was desperately in love with him.

The same went for Audric. He wanted Creole more than his next breath.

But it was never the right time.

Then life happened, and it kicked them both in the teeth.

One second they’re acting, and the next the anger is real, and neither one of them can stand to be near the other.

For years, they fight it out, one-upping each other to the point where neither one of them can be in the same room with each other without things going to hell.

Then one day their best friend dies, and they have to figure out a way to live without her.

There’s no fighting anymore, at least verbally. Physically, however? They let their bodies duke it out the fun way.

But in the end, neither one of them wins.

Goodreads


Get the Book



Amazon Nook Apple Kobo


In this series: Grumpy Sunshine, Look at Her and Die, Enemies to Lovers, Other Woman Drama, Ugly Duckling
Other books from this Author Hail Mary , Quit Your Pitchin', Too Bad So Sad, Mess Me Up, Trash Talkin'

I received this book for free from in exchange for an honest review. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.


my review


By chapter four I was in tears. If there was ever a book where you need to have your tissues ready then this is the one. Then I read chapter four and all I could think was “you sneaky devil you Lani Lynn Vale!” Then I kept reading and things got better and better. A lot happens early on and I was left with some serious feelings about all of it. Some were good, some were heartbreaking, and few made me want to get punchy. 

Audric and Creole were childhood friends but things happen and they end up drifting apart. This is their chance to reconnect and put the past behind them. They were so good together as a couple. There is such love and care there that you can tell they have known each other for years. There is plenty of spice when they come together as well. Creole was a wonderful character. She is someone who should be bitter and resentful with the things in her past but she is so hopeful and full of life. It is hard not to be drawn to her. 

I will say that every single time I read Creole Williams, my brains immediately went “lived down a dirt road He made homemade wine like nobody I know” For those who aren’t old enough to know that’s the beginning of the lyrics to Dust on the Bottle by David Lee Murphy and it came year I graduated high school. Just seeing her name Creole didn’t cause this to happen but the minute it got put together, I was young again and that song was stuck in my head. 

Audric had so much more going on than I ever expected. We know he is raising his little girl, Lottie, and in this book we get more of that story. My jaw hit the floor with all of this. That is all I am going to say and one of my favorite quotes happens in relation to this part of the story. The problem is I can’t tell you what it is because it gives too much away. When you read the book though you will know what I am thinking of when it happens. 

We do get a little more of Gunner in this story as well as Cakes. I always like learning about other members of MC and having them make things more real. When Parker from Maybe Don’t Wanna is mentioned it clicked into place for me. I don’t know why it didn’t previously but I knew we had met Gunner before and knowing he is Parker’s nephew makes much more sense with him now. I am more than ready for the next book now. 

Mistaken Identity Teaser 1 (1)

more in series


  • Grumpy Sunshine by LLV 2025Updated
  • Look at Her and Die by LLV 2025Updated
  • Enemies-to-Lovers-byLLV 2025Updated
  • Other-Woman-Drama-2025Updated
  • Ugly Duckling by LLV 2025 Updated
CONTENT ADVISORY SERIES REVIEWS

meet the author


five-stars

About Lani Lynn Vale

Lani Lynn Vale is a USA Today Bestselling Author of over thirty titles. She is married with three children, two dogs, two cats, a donkey, and a couple (a couple also meaning over twenty) chickens.

When she’s not writing, you can find her curled up in her favorite chair reading.

Lani is married with three children, and lives in the Great State of Texas.

Website | Facebook | Goodreads | Instagram

Category: Review Tags: Favorite Author, Favorite Series, Give Me Books Promotions

← Previous Post
Warriors of Iron by M J Porter | Book Review
Next Post →
Eagle and the Flame by Adam Lofthouse | Book Review

You may also like

Forget That Guy by Lani Lynn Vale Book Review
Forget That Guy by Lani Lynn Vale | Book Review
Maple & Moonlight by Daphne Elliot Book Review
Maple & Moonlight by Daphne Elliot | Excerpt Reveal
Barbarian's Heart by Ruby Dixon Book Review
Barbarian’s Heart by Ruby Dixon | Book Review

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Barrie says

    September 12, 2025 at 11:23 am

    It sounds like another great book in this series! I’m a bit behind in reading theses books, but I can’t wait to read this one!!

    Reply
    • Rita says

      September 13, 2025 at 9:10 pm

      You should because trust me when I say these are so good.

      Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

SC 2026 sidebar graphic


Hi, I’m Rita and I write all about books. I learned at a very early age just how much I love to read and getting lost in the worlds that books provide.

Find us online

  • Facebook
  • Goodreads
  • Instagram

Currently Reading

Nothing at the moment!

Recent Book Reviews

Tyre by Fiona Davenport  by Fiona DavenportForget That Guy by Lani Lynn ValeThe Bristlecone Writers' Group  by Lisa Williams KlineMaple & Moonlight  by Daphne ElliotWoden's Vengeance by Donovan CookMurder on an Irish Farm  by Carlene O'ConnorThe Arab-Israeli Cookbook by Robin SoansThe Lady of Galway Manor  by Jennifer DeibelBaking in the American South  by Anne ByrnThe Song That Moves the Sun  by Anna BrightThe Girl from Portofino by Siobhan DaikoThe Cake Bible, 35th Anniversary Edition by Rose Levy Beranbaum, Woody WolstonDesperately Seeking a Duchess by Christi CaldwellThe Final Target  by Nora RobertsTribune and the Sword by Adam LofthouseBe the Full Problem by Lani Lynn ValeThe Burning Pages by Paige SheltonStorm of Mercia  by MJ PorterTo Kiss a Demon  by Stephanie RoweThe Cursed King  by Abigail Owen

Join Me This Year

26 in 2026 -2 challenge updated sidebar- SC everything books page 2026
The Big Read Take Two
❤️ 𝐓𝐲𝐫𝐞 𝐛𝐲 𝐅𝐢𝐨𝐧𝐚 𝐃𝐚𝐯𝐞𝐧𝐩𝐨𝐫𝐭 𝐢𝐬 𝐎𝐔𝐓 𝐍𝐎𝐖 𝐚𝐧𝐝 𝐚𝐯𝐚𝐢𝐥𝐚𝐛𝐥 ❤️ 𝐓𝐲𝐫𝐞 𝐛𝐲 𝐅𝐢𝐨𝐧𝐚 𝐃𝐚𝐯𝐞𝐧𝐩𝐨𝐫𝐭 𝐢𝐬 𝐎𝐔𝐓 𝐍𝐎𝐖 𝐚𝐧𝐝 𝐚𝐯𝐚𝐢𝐥𝐚𝐛𝐥𝐞 𝐢𝐧 #𝐊𝐢𝐧𝐝𝐥𝐞𝐔𝐧𝐥𝐢𝐦𝐢𝐭𝐞𝐝!

Ares “Tyre” Costa always kept perfect control…until the club’s cool-headed treasurer became obsessed with Cecily Hayes. But the sweet swimming instructor has Olympic dreams that may take her away from Crossbend.

Even with an outside crew trying to steal the Redline Kings’ underground racing territory, Tyre’s real battle was tearing down Cecily’s walls. She was terrified her dreams would force her to walk away, but he’s determined to claim his woman.

📖 𝐖𝐡𝐚𝐭 𝐘𝐨𝐮'𝐥𝐥 𝐋𝐨𝐯𝐞
✔️ MC Romance
✔️ Morally Grey MMC
✔️ Age Gap
✔️ Protective Hero
✔️ Instalove
✔️ Opposites Attract 

❤️ 𝐆𝐞𝐭 𝐢𝐭 𝐇𝐞𝐫𝐞→ https://mybook.to/TyreRK

#instaloveinfluencers
NOW LIVE! “This series is truly one of the best I NOW LIVE! “This series is truly one of the best I have ever read” 

Forget That Guy by @lanilynnvale #DontDateHimSeries https://books2read.com/u/3JMAdg
NOW LIVE! Forget That Guy by @lanilynnvale is avai NOW LIVE! Forget That Guy by @lanilynnvale is available now!
 
Amazon: https://amzn.to/4cfzMnq
B&N: https://bit.ly/3OsjEa6
Kobo: https://bit.ly/4sXT9bP
Apple Books: https://apple.co/4vhjYcr
Universal: https://books2read.com/u/3JMAdg
 
Add to your Goodreads TBR ➩ https://t.ly/0KNMl
 
Holly Lorena Cain, formerly known as Georgina Lorena Cain, was well acquainted with rock bottom. She’s coasted along its rocky shores for years. It all started when her mother left her when she was barely old enough to understand. For years, her and her dad struggled to make ends meet. A dying cattle farm can’t run itself, and with her dad having cancer, it got harder and harder to hang on to land that’s been in her family for generations.

Just as she thinks that she’s finally made it, her father passes away and leaves every single thing he owns to their neighbor. The man that’d been worming his way into her father’s good graces while she’d been away pursuing higher education.

But she can’t be mad.

Being mad would mean that she has a soul left, but she sold that a long time ago to pay for college.

Once she comes to terms with her father and the land being gone, she moves back to Bear Pass and with one thing on her mind—avoid Denver at all costs. He can never know just how much it hurt that he stole her life away from her.

Only, he makes it impossibly hard to stay away.

He’s there around every corner. He offers her a place to stay. Makes sure she has a place to work. Fixes her car. Saves her from a kidnapper. Oh, and gives her everything her heart desires.

She stays away as best as she can, but she doesn’t stand a chance against Denver’s determination and charm. He’s there when no one else is, peeling her off the floor and propping her back up again each time she falls.

The gruff motorcycle club president with his scary glares and harsh work ethic has decided to make her his, and he won’t stand for her refusal.

He’s been protecting her for her entire life, and she doesn’t even know it.

He won’t stop now, even if she’s bound and determined to stay away.
 
#ForgetThatGuy #LaniLynnVale #DontDateHimSeries #romanticsuspense #enemiestolovers #alphamale #smalltown #givemebookspr
✨Did you see?✨MAPLE & MOONLIGHT by @daphneelliotau ✨Did you see?✨MAPLE & MOONLIGHT by @daphneelliotauthor is available NOW! Grab it in KU! 
#OneClickNow
https://a.co/d/0c9nLlkf 

Why you need to #ONECLICK this book…
🍂Single Mom
🍂New in Town
🍂Neighbors
🍂Hurt/Comfort
🍂Grumpy Maple Farmer
🍂Protective

As a single mom rebuilding my life from scratch, I don’t need help. And I  definitely don’t need the attention of a six-foot-three maple farmer with a beard and a hero complex who looks at me like I’m a problem he didn’t sign up for. 
#newbookalert #daphneelliot #smalltownromance @theauthor.agency
I just loved MAPLE & MOONLIGHT by @daphneelliotaut I just loved MAPLE & MOONLIGHT by @daphneelliotauthor! Grab it in KU!
#OneClickNow
https://a.co/d/0c9nLlkf
Why you need to #ONECLICK this book…
��Single Mom
��New in Town
��Neighbors
��Hurt/Comfort
��Grumpy Maple Farmer
��Protective
As a single mom rebuilding my life from scratch, I don’t need help. And I definitely don’t need the
attention of a six-foot-three maple farmer with a beard and a hero complex who looks at me like I’m a
problem he didn’t sign up for.
My landlord is broad-shouldered, permanently unimpressed, and entirely too comfortable telling me
when I’m wrong. I think he’s grumpy, rigid, and overprotective. He thinks I’m chaos in Crocs.
Falling for Josh Lawrence was never part of the plan.
But then he starts showing up.
For my son when he’s overwhelmed.
For my daughters when they need someone steady.
And for me when my hands won’t stop shaking.
I didn’t come to Vermont looking for a protector. I don’t need rescuing. But somewhere between harvest
festivals, pumpkin canoe races, and quiet mornings in the sugar shack, the man I swore was just an
annoyance becomes my safe place.
And when my dangerous past resurfaces and threatens the new life I’ve built, the grumpy maple farmer
next door becomes my fiercest protector, ready to stand by my side while I fight for my family.
 
Because it turns out maple farmers are a lot like their trees: quiet, stubborn, and surprisingly sweet
when the pressure builds.
#newbookalert #daphneelliot #smalltownromance @theauthor.agency
✨Let’s celebrate! It’s release day for MAPLE & ✨Let’s celebrate! It’s release day for MAPLE & MOONLIGHT by @daphneelliotauthor! Grab it in KU!
#OneClickNow
https://a.co/d/0c9nLlkf
Why you need to #ONECLICK this book…
��Single Mom
��New in Town
��Neighbors
��Hurt/Comfort
��Grumpy Maple Farmer
��Protective
As a single mom rebuilding my life from scratch, I don’t need help. And I definitely don’t need the
attention of a six-foot-three maple farmer with a beard and a hero complex who looks at me like I’m a
problem he didn’t sign up for.
My landlord is broad-shouldered, permanently unimpressed, and entirely too comfortable telling me
when I’m wrong. I think he’s grumpy, rigid, and overprotective. He thinks I’m chaos in Crocs.
Falling for Josh Lawrence was never part of the plan.
But then he starts showing up.
For my son when he’s overwhelmed.
For my daughters when they need someone steady.
And for me when my hands won’t stop shaking.
I didn’t come to Vermont looking for a protector. I don’t need rescuing. But somewhere between harvest
festivals, pumpkin canoe races, and quiet mornings in the sugar shack, the man I swore was just an
annoyance becomes my safe place.
And when my dangerous past resurfaces and threatens the new life I’ve built, the grumpy maple farmer
next door becomes my fiercest protector, ready to stand by my side while I fight for my family.
 
Because it turns out maple farmers are a lot like their trees: quiet, stubborn, and surprisingly sweet
when the pressure builds.
#newbookalert #daphneelliot #smalltownromance @theauthor.agency

Footer

Every Story Begins with a Conversation

Welcome to Storied Conversation, a space dedicated to he thoughtful discussion of books, exploring literary worlds one page at a time.

Categories

See all the posts in a particular category.

  • Facebook
  • Goodreads
  • Instagram
  • Twitter

Copyright © 2026 · Storied Conversation

Lexi Theme by Code + Coconut